EP report suggests to make robots ‘electronic persons’

Saturday, February 11, 2017

EP report suggests to make robots ‘electronic persons’

It is by no means a "science fiction" anymore: robots, which take over tasks in the service area. Cars that control themselves. Intelligent machines that replace industrial workers. Now the EU wants to retrofit and create a legal framework for robots.

MEP Gericke warns against the consequences of the Delvaux report: "transhumanism becomes law". "This is already problematic approach," says Arne Gericke (ECPM), MEP for the German Family Party and Vice-President of the Bioethics Working Group in the European Parliament. "However, the answers to address this issue given in the legislative proposal are wrong - even more: they are dangerous and break ethical taboos." For example, when the Luxembourg socialist Maddy Delvaux calls for a "legal personality for robots", he designs fundamental rights for intelligent machines and paves the way for humanoid beings. Next Thursday, the Strasbourg plenary will vote on a corresponding initiative law – Yesterday, Gericke has tabled a number of appropriate amendments.

Gericke, a bioethics expert, sees a scandal in the "legal personality right for robots". Although he is not a member of the committee on legal affairs, the member of ECPM has forged a last-minute coalition of Christian parliamentarians, who oppose the ad hoc plans of the Robot Lobby: "From the ethical point of view, such a hasty definition in the field of robotics is unacceptable and dangerous. "

In several plenary amendments, Gericke and his colleagues - including the Croatian MEP Marijana Petir - are trying to prevent at least “the worst points of the report". For example, they demand the deletion of a paragraph that requires a "legal personality" for robots and other machines with independent, artificial intelligence: "To put it plausibly, the report here makes the machine too human, it gives the robots a personnel ID - with devastating, incalculable consequences!"

Gericke pleas for large corporations and researchers to take responsibility: “Behind every machine there must always be human responsibility." Gericke also wants to highlight the references to "human enhancement" - the improvement and optimization of human bodies by robot elements: "Here we again want to play God - we make the terminator saga a sad reality. Transhumanism becomes law! Not one person with a conscience can accept this."

There is one more spicy detail to this report: "While we are discussing the most sensitive topic of robotics for the first time in Parliament, the rapporteur starts with a so-called INL report" - in short: a very rarely used instrument of the European Parliament to submit legislative proposals directly to the Council, which can be unanimously accepted or rejected by the latter. A method which is only reserved and foreseen for "interinstitutional concerns".

The vote on the report in the European Parliament is scheduled for next Thursday, with a debate in plenary on Wednesday. The report itself can be found online.

Head Office

Bergstraat 33
3811 NG Amersfoort
The Netherlands
+31 33 304 0011

Brussels Office

Belliardstraat 205
1040 Brussels
+32 22 301 300

Receive the monthly ECPM newsletter.

* indicates required
From 2010 on, the activities of the ECPM are financially supported by the European Parliament. The liability for any communication or publication by the ECPM, in any form and any medium, rests with the ECPM. The European Parliament is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein.